People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Feels a bit pricey but the pepperoni slices were good - pretty thin with a nice ratio of ingredients. The large pepperoni are nice - as far as my pizza eating has led me, Pinky Ring and Five Points are the best in/around Nashville. The two aren't comparable at all, totally different styles of pizza. You could eat both back to back and be happy without feeling like you've had too much pizza. ”
“ This might just be the best pizza in Nashville. Super friendly, pizza is always delicious.. highly recommend the Mikes Hot. Fantastic patio outside to have a slice and a brew. ”
“ Some of the best pizza I ever had. Really vibe with everything about this place. Cool hot sauce bar too ”
“ I tried the cheese and pepperoni pizza they were amazing! If you’ve tried Five points pizza and you like it , you’ll definitely love Pinky Ring. They also have vegan options which is amazing! Definitely a must try in Nashville! ”
“ If you’re looking for authentic, New York-style pizza in Madison, Pinky Ring Pizza is the spot! I stopped in and had a pepperoni slice, and it was absolutely incredible ..the perfect balance of crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni. I also ordered a Supreme pizza to go, with bacon added to half, and it was just as amazing. The flavor was outstanding — fresh ingredients, bold seasoning, and that classic foldable slice you expect from a real New York-style pie. On top of that, the service was top-notch: friendly, fast, and welcoming. Hands down, the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Pinky Ring Pizza definitely earned a spot on my go-to list! ”
“ Such a cute little spot with great pizza! The owner and employees were all so nice and helpful. We sampled a bunch of slices and they were all so good. The Madison Hot Pickle was my fav! The cute patio is covered which is a win. Will definitely be back! ”
“ When I think of great pizza this is it!! My wife and I went a couple weeks ago on a Sunday and they had a sign on the door that said. “ Sorry, No Dough. We sold out over the weekend “ I said to myself, self, I have to get that pizza!! Dropped in today and now I know why the sign was there! Amazing! I’m pretty basic on my pies. Traditional Pepperoni for me! The Cheese! The Sauce! The DOUGH!!! The Pepperoni!! All great ingredients. They let me know the dough sets for 3 days! They threw me a cookie on the house! Great job, Y’all!! ”
“ This is a great pizza spot! I’ve tried dine in and take out. The slices are a BIG NYC style! The vegan pepperoni is so flavorful. The pizzeria does have alcoholic beverages, canned cocktails and craft beers. It does get busy and seats can get filled before you know it. I’d recommend ordering ahead then eating in if you’re hangry! We usually have leftovers which I appreciate due to most places downsizing pizza sizes lately. ”
Menu
Classic Cheese
US$3.00Sausage
Cheese
Seasonal Veggie
Gluten Free Classic Cheese 10
US$5.00
About
Pinky Ring Pizza
If you find yourself in Madison, TN, make sure to swing by Pinky Ring Pizza. Nestled at 414 Gallatin Pike S, this vibrant pizzeria has quickly become a staple in the Nashville area, renowned for its authentic New York-style slices. With a menu that showcases a delightful variety of pizzas, Pinky Ring Pizza caters to all taste buds, offering everything from the classic cheese for just $3.00 to an indulgent Chicago Hot pizza priced at $30.00.
One of the standout features of Pinky Ring Pizza is the quality and flavor that comes through in every slice. Customers rave about the pepperoni pizza, highlighting its thin, crispy crust paired with a perfect ratio of savory, zesty sauce and melty cheese. As one customer aptly put it, “this might just be the best pizza in Nashville.” The vibrant reviews echo the sentiment that the culinary experience here is not to be missed.
Aside from their iconic pizzas, Pinky Ring Pizza also excels in small bites and salads. The garlic focaccia at $8.00 offers a fantastic way to start your meal, while the tomato caprese provides a refreshing compliment to the main event. Salads like the Bibb and Spring Greens add an extra touch of freshness, rounding out the menu beautifully.
The atmosphere at Pinky Ring Pizza is just as inviting as the food. With a fantastic patio, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy a slice under the Nashville sky while sipping on a craft brew. Customers have praised not only the delicious food but also the friendly service that makes every visit feel warm and welcome.
In addition to traditional options, Pinky Ring Pizza surprises many with its vegan selections. As one reviewer noted, “If you’ve tried Five Points Pizza and you like it, you’ll definitely love Pinky Ring.” This tells you what to expect—high-quality, flavorful slices that cater to diverse dietary needs without compromising taste.
Whether you're a pizza connoisseur or just someone looking for a great meal, Pinky Ring Pizza stands out with its fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and inviting atmosphere. It's more than just pizza; it's an experience. Don't miss your chance to see why so many have made this spot their go-to for delicious pizza in Nashville.
Book a table